OFT rule decisively in Circle’s favour, referring entire sector to Competition Commission

Office of Fair Trading Rule in Circle's Favour

08 December 2011

Circle welcomes the OFT's decision to refer the private healthcare market to the Competition Commission following its market study.

The OFT's market study was initiated in response to a formal complaint from Circle on the anti-competitive nature of the private healthcare market in September 2010.  The complaint was based on alleged anti-competitive agreements between national private healthcare providers and private medical insurance providers. 

Circle argued that these agreements - known in the industry as network agreements - act as a barrier to new entrants and result in consumer harm through restricted choice.  The OFT responded to Circle's complaint by launching a market study into private healthcare in December 2010, which concludes with today's report.  

In their report, the OFT accepted the arguments on the high barriers to entry in private healthcare and the consumer harm resulting from networks.  

Commenting, Circle CEO, Ali Parsa, said: 

'Circle has fought since our inception for a freer and fairer healthcare system.  We welcome today's decision which we believe will lead to the unleashing of entrepreneurialism and the unlocking of innovation at a time when our country needs it most.'

'This calls time on the anti-competitive games that for years have stifled innovation, shackled clinicians and shut down choice.'